Can an insurer depreciate labor when paying actual cash value?
Depreciation reduces some estimates from replacement cost to an actual-cash-value amount. Whether labor may be depreciated is a separate question that depends on policy wording and applicable law. Ask how the estimate was calculated before assuming a deduction is permitted or prohibited.
States are split. Some hold labor is not depreciable as a matter of law, some permit it when the policy says so clearly, and some have resolved it by statute.
The difference is often thousands of dollars on the first check, and it compounds if the depreciation is never recovered because repairs are not completed in time.
What this turns on
- The policy's definition of actual cash value, and whether it mentions labor or services.
- Whether the depreciation is itemized or applied as a single percentage to the whole estimate.
- Whether your state has addressed labor depreciation, and at what court level.
Labor depreciation rules by state: a research matrix
There is no single national rule answering whether an insurance company may depreciate labor when calculating actual cash value. The result can depend on the jurisdiction, the policy’s definitions, the type of property coverage and the date of the loss. This matrix summarizes identified authorities as research starting points; it is not a legal conclusion about a particular claim.
| Jurisdiction | Research status | Authority or limitation to examine |
|---|---|---|
| Alabama | Policy-dependent | Federal decisions distinguish policies that define ACV and depreciation from policies that do not. Review Ware and Arnold. |
| Alaska | Unsettled | The insurance division withdrew its 2024 prohibition bulletin in January 2025; verify current guidance. |
| Arizona | Restricted | Walker v. Auto-Owners bars labor depreciation when ACV and depreciation are undefined. |
| Arkansas | Permitted with terms | Ark. Code § 23-88-106 permits it for qualifying policies with approved language. |
| California | Restricted | 10 C.C.R. § 2695.9(f)(1) limits depreciation to components normally subject to repair and replacement during useful life. |
| Colorado | Permitted | Basham v. USAA is a reported federal decision applying Colorado law. |
| District of Columbia | Restricted | DISB Bulletin 25-IB-001-08/12 treats depreciation of labor and other nontangible items as an unfair claims practice. |
| Florida | Permitted | Goff v. State Farm Florida and Trinidad v. Florida Peninsula are commonly cited; confirm the policy and current treatment. |
| Georgia | No statewide answer identified | The reviewed survey identifies no controlling Georgia authority. Do not infer permission or prohibition; examine the policy and current Georgia sources. |
| Illinois | Restricted when undefined | Sproull v. State Farm bars the deduction when ACV and depreciation are undefined by the policy. |
| Indiana | Permitted | Travelers v. Armstrong authorized an across-the-board depreciation approach. |
| Kansas | Permitted | Graves v. American Family is the principal reported federal authority. |
| Kentucky | Unsettled | The state supreme court declined a certified question; Hicks addresses an undefined ACV term under federal appellate analysis. |
| Louisiana | Permitted | Shahan v. Allstate is a reported federal decision applying Louisiana law. |
| Michigan | Limited endorsement path | DIFS Bulletin 2024-26-INS addresses personal-lines policies and optional endorsement requirements. |
| Minnesota | Case by case | Wilcox v. State Farm allows fact-specific consideration when evidence logically bears on ACV. |
| Mississippi | Policy-dependent | Insurance Bulletin 2017-8 and Mitchell v. State Farm emphasize clear policy language and ambiguity concerns. |
| Missouri | Restricted unless explicit | Franklin v. Lexington bars labor depreciation absent specific policy language. |
| Montana | Restricted | The insurance commissioner’s advisory guidance and cited Montana authorities reject labor depreciation. |
| Nebraska | Permitted with limits | Henn permits it; Olson requires express policy authorization in the circumstances it addressed. |
| North Carolina | Permitted | Accardi v. Hartford Underwriters is the controlling state supreme court authority. |
| Ohio | Unsettled | Sixth Circuit decisions Perry and Cranfield reject the deduction when policy terms are undefined. |
| Oklahoma | Permitted | Redcorn and Branch are the principal Oklahoma Supreme Court decisions. |
| Pennsylvania | Policy-dependent | Kane, London and Papurello address partial losses, defined terms and replacement-cost holdbacks. |
| South Carolina | Permitted | Butler v. Travelers permits depreciation of embedded labor in the circumstances addressed. |
| Tennessee | Restricted | Lammert v. Auto-Owners holds that labor may not be depreciated under the policies considered. |
| Texas | Unsettled | Federal decisions applying Texas law have reached different results, including Tolar and Sims. |
| Vermont | Restricted by regulator | Department of Financial Regulation guidance states that labor costs may not be depreciated. |
| Virginia | Restricted by regulator | Administrative Letter 2025-06 states that labor and other nontangible items may not be depreciated. |
| Washington | Restricted | WAC 284-20-010 excludes repair or replacement labor from physical depreciation, with an intrinsic-labor exception. |
Sources and limits: Most rows are derived from the Horst Krekstein & Runyon state-law survey, last updated August 28, 2025. The District of Columbia row uses DISB Bulletin 25-IB-001-08/12, and Virginia uses Administrative Letter 2025-06. A label such as “permitted†or “restricted†is only a research classification; policy wording, later authority and claim facts may change the result. States not listed require separate current research.
What the depreciation line has to show
- The estimate showing replacement cost, depreciation, and the initial payment calculation.
- Any line-item split between material, labor, equipment, and other costs.
- The policy’s valuation provisions and relevant endorsements.
- The written explanation of age, condition, expected useful life, and depreciation method.
The same roof, two ACV calculations
If one line combines material and installation, a single depreciation amount may not show which cost components were reduced. Request the breakdown. A calculation that is hard to follow should be clarified before you decide what to challenge.
Testing whether labor was depreciated
Check the arithmetic separately from the legal question. Record the amount deducted and the stated basis. If replacement-cost benefits may be recoverable after repair, check the conditions, required documents, and deadlines in the policy.
Reading labor-depreciation cases without overreading them
The searches below are starting points, not verified legal advice. Read the actual opinion, identify the court and jurisdiction, compare the policy language and facts, and check later treatment before relying on it. A search result or software suggestion does not establish that a case governs your claim.
You can use this checklist without buying software. For help locating a regulator or legal aid, visit our free resource directory. For software cost assistance, contact us about free access.
Search the case law
Searches run on CourtListener, a free public database of U.S. court opinions from the Free Law Project. Add your state's court in their filters to narrow the results.
Last reviewed 24 October 2026. Case-law and statutory positions change; check current authority for your state before relying on any of this.
PAi Claims builds an itemized estimate from your own photos, policy and measurements, on your computer, with every line traced to its source. Brought to you by a 501(c)(3); the first claim is $20.
Get PAi Claims